Callaway man sentenced to prison for sexual assault charges
CUSTER COUNTY, Neb.— Timothy Rosentrater of Callaway was sentenced in Custer County District court on Thursday after entering a plea of guilty in May to several charges of sexual assault that occurred over a period eclipsing more than 20 years.
The 64 year old originally faced a single charge after being arrested in February of 2024 when a woman accused him of assaulting her during a seizure episode. As the case progressed, more women came forward to accuse Rosentrater of sexual assault instances that occurred when they were as young as 12 years old.
In May of 2024, Rosentrater was charged with 14 counts of sexual assault. An agreement with the state for a guilty or no contest plea in May dropped nine of the charges against Rosentrater. The recommendation made by the state was a minimum of 60 years of cumulative incarceration for the remaining charges, which Rosentrater pled guilty to.
Charges I and II: Sexual assault of a child (Class IIIA felonies)
Charges II and III: First degree sexual assault (Class II felonies)
Charge IV: Criminal attempt (Class IIA felony)
Several victim impact statements were read to the courtroom, either by victims in the case or on their behalf ahead of arguments from the state and defendant.
Deputy County Attorney Kayla Clark stated that the state doesn’t believe that Rosentrater takes accountability or understands the gravity of his actions despite making statements to make it sound like it. She added that statements he made to law enforcement were concerning, including ‘So you’re believing her over me?’ when being arrested.
Clark closed by saying the state believes that Rosentrater is an ‘incredible danger to society’, pointing to there being a felony charge for each victim that came forward but that they had detailed multiple times they had been assaulted. She re-stated the state’s recommendation of 60 years incarceration.
Attorney for the defense, Matt Furrow, spoke toward an extended period of probation or the minimum amount of incarceration (5-10 years) if probation was ruled inappropriate by the court. Furrow argued that Rosentrater had taken accountability for his actions, pointing mainly to working with law enforcement and entering a guilty plea. He also added that Rosentrater resisted when it was suggested that the victims be deposed, saying he ‘didn’t want to put them through that.’
Furrow closed by pointing to Rosentrater having no previous criminal charges or convictions and that pre-sentence investigations and evaluations showed that he was a low risk to recidivate. He stated once more an ask for probation or the minimum amount of incarceration.
Rosentrater gave a short statement to those in the courtroom, saying that he takes 100% responsibility for his actions, that he has nobody to blame but himself, and that his hope is for healing and closure for those that he hurt.
Judge Karin Noakes preceded sentencing with final statements of her own. She said his actions were appalling due to the victims looking for friendship with his daughter and being made to feel safe and secure, only for him to take advantage of their vulnerabilities. She added that she sees the crimes as pre-meditated and not impulsive because of Rosentrater’s identification of targets, building of relationships, and grooming.
Noakes spoke to the impact statements pointing to three types of lasting hurt from the victims: of trust broken, of the events of the assaults themselves, and the guilt of not coming forward earlier.
She added that the victims were justified in being concerned about whether they would be believed or not due to the image Rosentrater had built for himself in the community, stating, “They were concerned about friendships, their family, and even your family incredibly.” Noakes said she is amazed by the concern young children have for others even after being the victim of a horrible crime and that ‘people like you (Rosentrater)’ know that.
Judge Noakes sentenced Rosentrater to 4 to 5 years incarceration for each sexual assault of a child charge and 10 to 15 years for the first degree sexual assault and criminal attempt charges. The charges were ordered to be served consecutively and Rosentrater was given credit for 588 days of incarceration served. He will serve a minimum of 19 years before becoming eligible for parole, pursuant to Nebraska’s ‘Good Time Law’.